When it comes to digital marketing, businesses face a crucial question: Should we handle everything in-house, outsource to a specialized agency, or adopt a DIY (Do-It-Yourself) approach? Each option has advantages and drawbacks, and the best choice depends on your company’s resources, skills, and long-term goals.
This guide will help you weigh the options of Outsourcing, In-House, or DIY to determine the best strategy for your business.
1. Evaluate Your Team’s Skills and Capacity
Outsource
Advantage: Agencies bring specialized skills, experience, and tools to the table. They’ve likely worked with various businesses, giving them a broad perspective on what works across industries.
Disadvantage: Outsourcing can result in losing direct control over campaigns, requiring effective communication and coordination to ensure your vision is executed correctly.
In-House
Advantage: With an in-house team, you maintain complete control over strategy, messaging, and brand identity. You also have the flexibility to pivot quickly without waiting for external partners.
Disadvantage: Building and maintaining a highly skilled in-house team can be expensive and time-consuming. Your team may need more breadth of expertise required for a multi-channel digital marketing strategy.
DIY (Do-It-Yourself)
Advantage: DIY allows you to bootstrap your marketing efforts, utilizing your existing team. This approach gives you complete control; your team can learn and adapt as needed.
Disadvantage: Without the necessary expertise, your team may not be able to keep up with the latest marketing trends and tools. Dividing responsibilities among team members who already have primary roles can lead to inconsistent execution and reduced focus.
How We Can Help:
According to HubSpot, only 24% of marketers feel their company’s marketing team is performing well across all areas of digital marketing. This suggests that many in-house and DIY teams may struggle to execute complex, multi-channel strategies on their own.
Outsource: Our agency can manage and streamline multiple teams, ensuring your campaigns run efficiently without sacrificing quality.
In-House: We can direct your in-house team, help build your strategy, offer expert guidance, and ensure your team is fully equipped to handle digital marketing.
DIY: Even if you choose a DIY approach, we can plug in to perform specialized tasks, provide training, or offer strategic direction via weekly calls to keep your marketing on track.
2. Assess Budget Constraints
On average, small businesses spend 7-8% of their revenue on marketing, with digital marketing often consuming the most significant portion.
Outsource
Advantage: While agencies may have higher upfront costs, they can save you money in the long run by avoiding expensive hires, training, and tool investments. Agencies also scale with your business, allowing you to adjust your budget as needed.
Disadvantage: Outsourcing can be seen as costly, especially if you’re not ready for ongoing retainer fees. Additionally, any changes or new initiatives may come at extra costs.
In-House
Advantage: Once the team is in place, in-house can be cost-effective, as the team works solely on your projects without the ongoing retainer fees often associated with agencies.
Disadvantage: The costs of hiring, training, and providing the necessary tools can add up quickly. You also have fixed overhead expenses, even during slow periods.
DIY
Advantage: DIY is often seen as the most budget-friendly option, especially for startups or small businesses. You save on agency fees and external consultants by leveraging your team and free or low-cost tools.
Disadvantage: The hidden costs of learning, making mistakes, and dedicating time to activities outside your team’s core strengths can reduce overall efficiency and effectiveness.
How We Can Help:
Outsource: We offer flexible pricing structures that allow you to scale your efforts based on your needs and budget.
In-House: We can offer consultation and training to maximize the efficiency of your in-house resources.
DIY: We can step in for project-based needs or offer expert assistance as your budget allows, ensuring your DIY efforts are successful without requiring a full-time commitment.
3. Consider Speed and Flexibility
Outsource
Advantage: Agencies have the resources to expedite campaigns and produce quick results without sacrificing quality. They can scale rapidly to meet urgent demands and manage multiple projects simultaneously.
Disadvantage: Communication delays can sometimes slow down decision-making. If your business needs a quick pivot, you might experience delays in execution compared to an in-house or DIY team.
In-House
Advantage: With an in-house team, you can pivot campaigns quickly and adjust tactics as necessary. No external approvals are required, allowing for greater flexibility.
Disadvantage: A stretched-thin in-house team may struggle with bandwidth issues, making delivering campaigns quickly, especially during peak periods, hard.
DIY
Advantage: DIY gives you immediate control and flexibility. You can move at your own pace and adjust your marketing strategy as needed without waiting on third parties.
Disadvantage: The speed of implementation may suffer if your team lacks experience or is juggling multiple roles, slowing down campaign execution and adjustments.
How We Can Help:
A survey by Deloitte found that 57% of companies believe that outsourcing allows them to focus on core business activities while leaving marketing to the experts. Agencies like ours are often equipped with the latest tools and methodologies to deliver quick, high-quality results.
Outsource: We can quickly execute strategies and pivot when necessary, freeing your team to focus on core business functions.
In-House: We can step in to support your team during high-demand periods, ensuring deadlines are met without overwhelming your staff.
DIY: We provide a flexible, on-demand solution to help execute specific tasks, allowing your team to stay nimble without taking on too much responsibility.
4. Look at Your Long-Term Goals
Outsource
Advantage: Agencies provide long-term strategic support, offering continuity and a big-picture perspective that can help scale your digital marketing efforts over time.
Disadvantage: Some agencies may lack a deep understanding of your brand’s internal culture and goals, which could result in strategies that don’t align perfectly with your vision.
In-House
Advantage: Your in-house team has a deep understanding of your business and can develop long-term strategies that align perfectly with your brand’s mission and vision.
Disadvantage: Your team might not have the experience or resources to think strategically on a long-term scale, especially if they’re focused on day-to-day tasks.
DIY
Advantage: DIY allows for complete customization of long-term goals, as you’re in total control of your marketing strategy. You can adjust your plans as you learn and grow.
Disadvantage: The lack of long-term strategic expertise can hinder the success of your efforts. Your DIY strategy might be inconsistent or misaligned with business growth without proper planning.
How We Can Help:
Outsource: We offer long-term strategic partnerships to keep your digital marketing campaigns on track for the future.
In-House: We can provide ongoing consulting and strategy development to ensure your team remains aligned with your long-term goals.
DIY: We offer guidance and assistance to help you develop long-term strategies while maintaining control of execution within your team.
5. Weigh the Need for Specialization
Outsource
Advantage: Agencies typically have teams of specialists with deep expertise in key areas like SEO, content marketing, and paid advertising. This is hard to replicate in-house without hiring multiple experts.
Disadvantage: Relying on external specialists may reduce your ability to foster in-house expertise, limiting your control and knowledge over time.
In-House
Advantage: Having specialists in-house allows for better integration with your business and long-term skill-building.
Disadvantage: Hiring multiple specialists is costly, and it may be challenging to find talent with expertise in every necessary area.
DIY
Advantage: DIY allows your team to learn and grow their skills over time, potentially reducing reliance on external experts.
Disadvantage: It’s difficult for non-specialists to keep up with the latest trends, tools, and strategies across multiple disciplines, leading to gaps in execution.
How We Can Help:
Outsource: We provide specialized talent in all key areas of digital marketing, ensuring you have the expertise you need when you need it. We offer ongoing staff training and support and provide standard operating procedures (SOPs) so that our clients own their marketing operations.
In-House: We can supplement your in-house team with specialists to handle tasks that require deep expertise, helping them grow while delivering results.
DIY: We can plug into specific areas where your team lacks expertise, ensuring your campaigns stay effective while your team learns.
Conclusion: Finding the Right Balance
The choice between Outsourcing, In-House, or DIY depends on your business’s specific needs, goals, and resources. Many companies find that a hybrid approach works best, with some tasks handled in-house and others outsourced.
At JJM, we work with companies of all sizes and types of marketing teams to reach their digital marketing objectives. Whether it’s managing multiple teams of outsourced specialists to work towards a common strategy, assisting an in-house marketing team with their workload and strategic direction, or empowering small business owners to learn and be able to handle their digital marketing themselves, we have been there and done it all.
Contact us today to find out how we can meet your business’s digital marketing needs today.
Commentaires